Stop Being a Yes-Man: The Truth About Why Trust Builds Fortunes

Let’s be real: trust is one of those things everyone says they want, but few people actually know how to build. It’s like the gym membership of leadership principles—great in theory, ignored in practice.

Yet at Amazon, Earn Trust isn’t just some corporate buzzword plastered on a wall. It’s a daily, often awkward, sometimes humbling commitment that separates great teams from dysfunctional ones.

Here’s the kicker: trust isn’t about being everyone’s best friend or playing nice at meetings. It’s about saying, “Yeah, I screwed up,” when you did. It’s about calling out a bad idea, even if it makes things uncomfortable. And it’s about doing what you said you would, every damn time, no matter how inconvenient it gets.

At Amazon, “Earn Trust” shows up in unexpected ways. It’s the VP who admits in front of their team that their strategy bombed and needs rethinking. It’s the junior engineer who challenges a flawed plan in a room full of senior leaders, backed by solid data. It’s not always pretty, but it works. And if you can master this, you’ll not only thrive at Amazon—you’ll thrive anywhere.

In this post, we’re going to break down Earn Trust—what it really means, why it matters, and how you can start practicing it in your own life. No fluff, no corporate jargon. Just practical lessons, a few battle-tested tips, and one or two cringe-worthy mistakes to learn from. Let’s dive in.

Trust is earned, not given

Do they ask this in the interviews?

Yes. Amazon-wide for all L4+ and roles.

Question:

“Tell me about a time when you disagreed with a team member or leader’s opinion. How did you handle it, and what was the result?”

Reasonable Answer:

“In one project, a colleague suggested a solution that I believed wasn’t scalable. I shared my concerns in a team meeting and explained why I thought we should explore alternatives. The team considered my input, but we ultimately went with the original plan. While I disagreed, I respected the decision and supported the implementation.”

Let’s analyze this response:

✅ Shows willingness to voice concerns.
❌ Lacks details on how the disagreement was handled.
❌ Doesn’t show how trust was maintained or built during the process.
❌ Misses the impact of the actions on the team or the project outcome.

Better Answer:

“During a system redesign project, a senior team member proposed an approach to improve performance. While their idea was interesting, I noticed it didn’t address potential scalability issues, especially for future customer growth. I scheduled a one-on-one discussion with them first to avoid calling them out in front of the team. I explained my perspective with data from previous projects, highlighting where similar approaches had failed under high traffic. I asked thoughtful questions to better understand their rationale and shared alternative solutions that could meet both short- and long-term goals.”

“In the next team meeting, I respectfully raised my concerns and shared the data I’d gathered. To my surprise, other team members also voiced similar doubts, leading to a collaborative discussion. Together, we refined the proposal, ultimately integrating parts of both approaches into a scalable solution. By addressing the issue respectfully and with evidence, I not only helped the team avoid potential pitfalls but also strengthened trust with the senior team member. They later thanked me for challenging their idea in a constructive way.”

Why This Works:

✅ Demonstrates respectful and thoughtful communication.
✅ Uses data to back up concerns and drive the discussion.
✅ Maintains trust through one-on-one conversations and a collaborative approach.
✅ Highlights a positive outcome and improved team dynamics.

What does it mean in practice?

Here’s the deal: trust isn’t about handshakes, smiles, or playing office politics. It’s about showing up, owning your crap, and delivering results. At Amazon, it’s the glue that keeps teams running at a thousand miles an hour without falling apart.

“Earn Trust” means:

• Listen like you give a damn. Don’t just wait for your turn to talk—actually hear people out.
• Speak the truth. Even when it’s awkward. Even when it sucks. Say it straight, but with respect.
• Own your mistakes. Seriously, stop the blame game. If something’s broken, call it out and fix it.
• Do the thing you promised. No excuses, no drama—just get it done.

And here’s the kicker: it’s not about agreeing on everything. Disagreeing respectfully? That’s trust in action. Because when people know you’re honest, reliable, and self-critical, they’ll trust you—even when you challenge them.

Social cohesion

Let’s talk about a dirty little secret of teamwork: social cohesion isn’t always your friend. Yeah, you heard that right.

Jeff Bezos himself has said it—too much “getting along” can kill a team’s ability to solve real problems. Why? Because when everyone’s too afraid to rock the boat, bad ideas sail straight to failure.

Here’s the deal: a team that prioritizes harmony over honesty becomes a yes machine. Nobody speaks up. Nobody questions the obvious flaws. Everyone nods along to avoid the awkwardness of disagreement. And then what? You build the wrong product. You chase the wrong metrics. You solve the wrong problem.

At Amazon, challenging opinions isn’t just encouraged—it’s essential. When done respectfully, pushing back sharpens ideas, uncovers blind spots, and forces everyone to think deeper. The best teams thrive on friction, not fake smiles.

So, let me ask you this: would you rather hurt someone’s feelings for five minutes or let your entire team waste months solving the wrong problem? Tough love might sting, but it saves lives—okay, maybe just careers—but you get the point. Challenge the idea. Fix the problem. Move forward.

How to Apply This in Your Team (Without Causing a Riot)

Alright, you’re sold on the idea of challenging opinions. But how do you do it without turning your team into a battlefield? Here’s your playbook:

1. Start with respect. Challenge the idea, not the person. It’s not about proving someone wrong—it’s about finding the best solution.
2. Ask the hard questions. Don’t just nod along. Dig deeper. “Why do we think this will work?” “What’s the data to back it up?” Make questioning a habit.
3. Create a safe space. Let your team know it’s okay to disagree. Reward people who speak up, even if their ideas don’t always land.
4. Model it yourself. Admit when you’re wrong. Show that being challenged doesn’t threaten you—it helps you grow.
5. Focus on the outcome. Keep the end goal in sight. This isn’t about who’s right—it’s about what’s right for the team and the customer.

Want a high-performing team? Teach them that challenging ideas is a sign of respect, not rebellion. That’s how you turn social cohesion into productive collaboration.

Why “Earn Trust” Is the Secret Sauce for Success

Here’s the harsh truth: nobody trusts a yes-man. You know the type—the person who nods at everything, avoids conflict like it’s the plague, and sugarcoats feedback to the point of uselessness. Sure, they’re easy to work with, but when it really matters—when the stakes are high, and you’re staring down a tough decision—do you turn to them for advice? Hell no.

At Amazon, and honestly, in real life, trust is built on two things: truth and guts. People trust you when you’re honest, even when it’s uncomfortable. They trust you when you have the courage to say, “This won’t work,” or, “Here’s where we’re failing.” Because when the stakes are high, nobody wants someone who says what they think you want to hear. They want someone who tells it like it is, no matter how much it stings.

Think about it: When you need real feedback, do you go to the person who sugarcoats everything? Or do you go to the blunt friend, the one who calls out your BS and tells you exactly what needs to change? Exactly. That’s why “Earn Trust” isn’t just crucial for Amazon—it’s a life skill. Being honest and reliable earns you a reputation as the person who gets sh*t done and makes others better.

The bottom line? Yes-men fade into the background. Truth-tellers rise to the top. If you want people to trust you—not just agree with you—get real, speak up, and start delivering. Trust isn’t given. It’s earned.

Conclusion

At Amazon—and in life—trust isn’t handed out like candy. It’s earned through your actions, your honesty, and your ability to show up when it matters most. Leaders who listen intently, speak candidly, and deliver consistently are the ones who build lasting relationships and drive meaningful results.

If you want to succeed, stop aiming to please and start aiming to be trusted. Be the person who challenges bad ideas with respect, admits mistakes without excuses, and backs every claim with action. That’s how you earn trust.

And here’s the real kicker: once people trust you, they’ll follow you. They’ll rely on you. They’ll come to you when things are falling apart because they know you’ll be honest, reliable, and real. That’s not just a leadership principle—it’s a superpower. Earn trust, and you’ll do more than succeed. You’ll lead.

• If you want to know more about this topic, signup for Office Hours
• If you have an interview lined up, schedule a mock interview
• If you need guidance to succeed in your current role and get promoted, or prepare to switch, signup for monthly mentorship